Stratocaster vs. Telecaster: Which Should You Choose?

Are humbuckers or single-coils better? What about set necks vs. bolt-on construction? Do you prefer vintage vibes or more modern-minded guitars? The guitar world has no shortage of impassioned arguments about which legendary brand or revered model rises above the rest.

As fun as it is to partake in these heated debates, the truth is that there is no universal “best” when it comes to music gear. While Sweetwater must remain impartial to the guitar world’s most lively discussions, you and all the other musicians out there don’t! Whether you’re mercilessly defending your six-string champion’s superiority in all caps in a YouTube comment thread or quietly voting with your wallet, most of us tend to lean toward one side of any guitar-related debate.

There’s no objective means to measure which pedal, amp, or guitar is “best,” but there’s also almost certainly a “best” choice for your respective style and musical taste. So, how does Sweetwater, an impartial judge, possibly help you in a thoroughly partial decision such as choosing between the legendary Fender Telecaster and Fender Stratocaster electric guitars? Easy. We gave two of our own guitar-expert writers free reign to answer a simple question: Between the Strat and the Tele, which model is best for you and why?

Why I Choose the Telecaster

By Cameron Day

For my musical taste, the decision between Stratocaster and Telecaster is a simple one — the Telecaster wins, every time. Why? Tone, reliability, simplicity, and the small fact that I’ve been playing Telecasters since I bought my first Mexican Standard model as a teenager in the late aughts. Since then, my playing has shifted rather dramatically from hard-edged indie rock and classic rock to the milder sounds of Chet Atkins-style Travis picking and questionable attempts at playing Johnny Smith-style solo jazz guitar. And while I’ve taken a few extended leaves of absence from the Tele’s good graces — including an ongoing love affair with Fender offsets and (gasp) even a Strat or two — there’s never been a time in my life when I’ve picked up my #1 Telecaster and thought, “No, this simply won’t do.”

Slab-bodied Simplicity

The Telecaster is not an elegant instrument. Compared to the swooping contours and space-age stylings of the Stratocaster, the Tele is positively rustic; it’s essentially a cutting board with a neck and strings attached to it. It’s no surprise that it was Leo Fender’s first attempt at a mass-produced solidbody guitar, as the Tele retains a decidedly assembly-line vibe when compared to the refined hollowbody instruments that came before it and the sleek, sculpted solidbodies that would follow. It’s the electric guitar distilled to its very essence — no bells or whistles required.

For many, the Telecaster’s simplicity is a negative. For me and countless other Telecaster proponents, it’s a strength. Besides its inherent reliability and ruggedness (more on those qualities later), I argue that the Telecaster’s utilitarian-workhorse vibe provides it with the chameleonic ability to slot into almost any genre with little visual or sonic baggage — a claim that my jazz guitar teachers in college didn’t quite agree with, considering my gaudy Surf Green Telecaster Custom stood out unabashedly among the sea of conservatively styled hollowbodies.

A Bridge over Twangy Waters

Tele proponents like me often argue that the Telecaster epitomizes reliability in six-string form, but what really separates the Telecaster from the Stratocaster in that regard? Both instruments essentially share the same neck construction, so it can’t be that. What about the Strat’s electronics? Yes, they’re more complex than the Telecaster’s two-pickup, two-knob setup, but they’re not necessarily any less reliable. The answer lies a little bit farther down: the Telecaster’s signature “ashtray” bridge plate and barrel saddles.

The Telecaster’s positively prehistoric bridge setup may not offer the expressive capabilities of the Strat’s synchronized tremolo system, yet I’ve always found it to be significantly more reliable, stabler, and easier to set up. Strat fans, I hear you — I’m well aware that the Stratocaster’s trem can be set up to deliver a superb level of stability. I’m also aware that some Strats come with a fixed bridge. However, the point remains that a locked-down hardtail bridge, by its very nature, will always be stabler than a bridge system with moving parts. Moreover, I have always found the Telecaster’s string-through-body bridge to supply superior sustain when compared to the Stratocaster.

For many guitarists, this point ends the argument. Does your playing style benefit from the addition of a whammy bar? If so, then you might be better served by picking up a Stratocaster or one of the admittedly few Tele-style guitars that come equipped with a trem unit. So much of my musical life has been spent playing acoustic guitars and trem-less guitars that I’m more than happy to trade all the dive-bombs in the world for the rock-solid tuning stability and enhanced sustain of the Telecaster’s clunky, old barrel-style bridge.

Time-honored Tones

Finally, we get to the real crux of the matter: tone. There’s no denying that the Telecaster is the underdog here when it comes to tonal options, competing with one fewer pickup and two fewer switching positions than your standard Stratocaster. Still, I’m of the opinion that the Tele’s humble two-pickup setup is more than a match for the Stratocaster’s quintet of switching options.

I’ll start with what I and most other Tele lovers consider the model’s strongest sound: the twangy, bold, and biting bridge pickup traditionally encased in its ashtray bridge cover with brass or steel saddles. Far more aggressive and solid-sounding than the Strat’s bridge pickup to my ears, the Telecaster’s classic single-coil bridge pickup has served me well in all stages of my musical development. It’s more often than not my go-to sound when playing anything other than solo guitar pieces, giving a truly glorious bark when lighting up an old-school tube amp’s preamp section.

The neck pickup is a little trickier. I will defend the Telecaster’s chromed-out neck pickup to the bitter end, but I’ll also begrudgingly admit I’m somewhat in the minority in that regard. It sounds rather dark, not quite as brilliant as the sparkle of a Strat pickup and not nearly as full as a proper humbucker or P-90 pickup. In fact, Telecaster players — famously including Keith Richards, Andy Summers, and two of my own personal Telecaster heroes: jazz guitarists Bill Frisell and Julian Lage — routinely sling Telecasters modded with P-90s or other more esoteric neck pickups. Fender even offers several Telecaster neck-pickup options designed to emulate the sound of a Strat!

To tell the truth, I’ve found much to love in just about every Telecaster variation that I’ve had the pleasure to play — even those sacrilegious hybrid Telecasters that sport Stratocaster neck pickups. But whether you’re talking high-power ’70s-style H/S Telecaster Specials or tried-and-true Butterscotch Blonde Broadcasters, my opinion is that the Telecaster reigns supreme as Leo Fender’s crowning achievement.

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Why I Choose the Stratocaster

By Mac McDonough

To start, I want to make a confession: I love Telecasters. In fact, up until a few years ago, my main daily driver was a Tele. But now I play a Strat-style guitar. Why the switch? Simply put, my playing style evolved. I started exploring the world outside the Springsteen-esque singer/songwriter material and sludgy alternative rock I had been plugging away at since the late 1980s, and I wanted to find a guitar that could grow with me. As I delve into more technical aspects of heavy melodic rock and attempt to perfect my meager jazz-fusion stylings, I’ve found that the Stratocaster, with its sleek contours, superior upper-fret access, broad tonal palette, and expressive tremolo system, checks all the right boxes.

Playing in Contoured Comfort

Up until the past few years, most of my guitar playing was tailored toward “serving the song.” Sure, I would rip a solo here and there, but my musical vocabulary contained mostly chords and lower-register leads. For the most part, I wasn’t attempting to push my playing past the bare minimum that was required to get my point across. As such, I never found anything particularly limiting about my Telecaster; its pragmatic design more than got the job done. And there’s certainly something to be said for how a heavy slab of wood resonates when you play an open chord through a loud amp!

As I began exploring the fretboard more, however, I began to find my Tele somewhat unwieldy, especially when I tried to play more demanding things past the 12th fret. That’s when I realized that the contoured body found on Stratocasters and other Strat-style guitars makes these instruments extremely comfortable to play. What’s more, the extra cutout on their upper horn, at least for me, makes nailing high-register parts much easier. That’s not to say that you can’t go full kamikaze on a Tele. After all, Brad Paisley and the session cats in Nashville do it all the time. But, as an aspiring technical player with questionable potential, I do my best to remove as many physical roadblocks as possible.

On the Road to Whammy-ville

I used to hate whammy bars. I couldn’t find anything interesting to do with them, and I couldn’t stand the way floating trem systems got all wonky when you bent a note or broke a string. Simply put, I greatly preferred the stability of a hardtail bridge. Seriously, I could (and did) beat my Telecaster’s bridge mercilessly all throughout the grunge era while sweating under stage lighting and dodging flying beer bottles, and my Tele just laughed it off.

All of the above is true. So, what made me learn to love the Strat’s tremolo? The answer is simple: I discovered dive-bombs, harmonic squealies, scoops and doops, and all the other whammy-bar tricks of the trade. Are trem systems less stable than hardtails? Yes. Do I want to give up my whammy-abuse habit? No. It’s as plain as that.

Just for the record, it’s not like a floating trem is unreliable — especially if it’s set up properly. What’s more, in my case, I went completely off the rails and got myself a guitar with a double-locking Floyd Rose. Sure, it’s got its quirks, but it allows me to expand my playing with techniques and sonic textures that would be completely unavailable to me on a Strat with a hardtail bridge.

Expanded Sonic Flexibility

When I was playing singer/songwriter material and grunge-flavored rock, I found my Telecaster’s bridge pickup to be just the ticket. It was bold and snarling and pushed my amp beautifully. When I got tired of 60-cycle hum with distortion and fuzz pedals, I solved the problem with a single-coil-voiced stacked humbucker. I also got lots of mileage out of my Tele’s neck pickup; its dark, almost jazz-like tone is difficult to achieve with any other model of guitar.

That said, once I started seeking new sonic textures, I began to find the Tele’s two-single-coil configuration and three-way switching confining. That’s where the Stratocaster’s three-pickup design and five-way switching came into play. I also appreciate the versatility of the Strat’s three-knob control layout. As for tone, the glassy, bell-like sound of a Stratocaster neck pickup is a thing of beauty whether you play it clean or through truckloads of high gain. And positions two and four unlock the quacky sweet spots that have been fueling hit songs since well before I was born.

Now it’s time for another confession: I don’t like the stock Stratocaster single-coil bridge pickup, and because of that, every Strat and Strat-style guitar I’ve owned has had a humbucker installed in the bridge position. For me, an HSS Stratocaster is the apex of electric-guitar design. You can scream and roar through a Marshall stack with PAF-flavored fury, get your British-Invasion chime on, nail swampy blues tones, and achieve any other sound you’re aiming for — the sky’s the limit!

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

Add to cartLearn MoreAdd to list

You Probably Need Both!

So, Stratocaster vs. Telecaster: which will you choose? It’s a tough question best answered with an exuberant “both”! And while we hope that the opinions of our two guitar experts will aid you in choosing your next six-string, our Sweetwater Sales Engineers would love to hear your opinions on the matter. Make sure to give them a call at (800) 222-4700 for professional advice on picking out your next guitar so that you can take the Strat vs. Tele debate into your own hands!
The post Stratocaster vs. Telecaster: Which Should You Choose? appeared first on inSync.